“We can’t keep taking trips during the school year because you’re getting older, and it’s getting harder to miss school,” I told my daughter. But here’s the thing: I’ve been telling my 11-year-old daughter this for at least the past three summers.
Every year, we, like so many other families, struggle on deciding if we should or should not take our children out of school for a family vacation. Whatever the reason might be— smaller crowds, cheaper prices, a great opportunity—families have lots to weigh before pulling kids out of school for a vacation during the school year.
What Educators Think of Taking Kids Out of School for Vacation
Mom of three and longtime educator Holly Hatcher-Frazier sees both sides of the coin. When she was in a school leadership position, she discouraged parents from taking family vacations during the school year. “It is disruptive to learning and curriculum is designed to account for regularly scheduled school vacations set by the administration,” Hatcher-Frazier said. “Taking additional vacations throughout the school year can hinder academic progress for a student because there may be gaps in instruction due to absences.”
EASY PLANNING: 7 Family Adventures Where Someone Else Does the Planning
However, the Pittsburgh mom who gained famed when she starred with her daughter Nia on the reality show Dance Moms, says the emotional side creeps in when you’re looking at it from the other side of family travel. “I can find valid reasons to justify that decision and there is no denying family vacations can be incredibly educational, worthwhile experiences,” Hatcher-Frazier said. “However, weighing the advantages and disadvantages of pulling kids out of school for family vacations I would still err on the side of resisting the urge. Of course there are extenuating circumstances that may be once in a lifetime opportunities which need to be considered.”
That’s exactly what happened to my family. We were given a chance to travel on an Adventures by Disney trip to South Africa. The 10-day trip was packed with amazing experiences including safaris, first-hand accounts of apartheid and Nelson Mandela, and African cultural experiences.
Tips for Taking Your Kids Out of School for a Trip
The problem was, the trip was scheduled for right after the school year started. In situations like this, Hatcher-Frazier said if you decide to take the trip, talk to school officials as soon as possible. “Telling the school the day before that your child will be missing school for a week for a family vacation does not usually sit well for many,” she said.
She also noted that it’s not a fair expectation to assume teachers will prepare work ahead of time for your child for unexcused absences. “Curating lesson plans for an individual child is creating more work for a teacher in addition to the teachers’ regular responsibilities, lesson plans and workload,” she said. “If parents treat the school officials with reasonable expectations, courtesy and respect then I think most schools will try their best to work together with parents to ensure the success of the child.”
MORE DECISIONS: Deciding Between a Land and River Trip with Adventures by Disney
Once I saw the itinerary for our trip to South Africa, I knew there would be no time for school work. It was a jam-packed family trip, but it was filled with activities that included some extraordinary form of learning every single day. And from the first day of the trip I knew we made the right decision to experience this family vacation even though it meant missing school.
Travel As Education
One day in school, my children will be reading about apartheid and learning about how it affected not just South Africa but the entire world. During our trip, we were able to have insightful conversations with people who experienced that time in history.
Every day was filled with educational experiences, from something as simple as learning that traffic lights in South Africa are called robots to finding out the meaning behind all the colors of the South African flag. The animal interactions on the trip were unreal, and with them came lessons on the lions, giraffes, monkeys, and everything else we saw.
BIG ADVENTURES WITH KIDS: 11 Best Tour Companies for Families
By the end of our first safari ride, my three kiddos were even able to tell which animal left the droppings we saw. They also were taught how to make a toothbrush out of tree branches and what tree bark can be grounded down to make toothpaste.
There was tons of information thrown at my children, and I do wonder what they will retain. My daughter kept a daily journal, which I know we’ll all continue to look back on to help remind us what we learned and how we learned it.
The Benefits of Trusting Your Gut
Once we returned, there was some makeup work that needed to be done, but everyone, including their teachers and school administrators, agreed this was an incredible experience. Hatcher-Frazier said in the end, trust your gut.
“You know your child best and whether or not this is a vacation that can’t wait until an upcoming school break,” she said. “Parents need to consider the consequences of their child missing school. Does your child work independently? Most likely your child will have to do work on their own without the help of an instructor or in class discussion if they miss class. Does your child take initiative?”
Truth be told, in the weeks after the trip, my daughter struggled a bit with all the makeup work. There were some nights when I questioned if we made the right decision because I hated seeing her so stressed. In the future, I’m not sure we’ll be so quick to take our children out of school for a trip we can easily reschedule. However, if another once-in-a-lifetime opportunity arises, we’ll give it careful consideration.
Once all the work was made up, I asked my daughter and she said she would 100 percent do the trip again. As a family, I think we made the right choice. We have amazing memories we talk about daily. The trip allowed us to make friends with people from all over the world whom we otherwise would have never met, and it taught my children to differentiate between rhino poop and zebra poop—a lesson I don’t think they’ll ever learn in the classroom.
