What’s the Difference Between a Vacation Rental Agency vs. Booking Platform?

Vacation rental agencies and booking platforms work differently and provide different levels of assistance if something goes wrong.
Ed Perkins
Posted by by Ed Perkins
Vacation home patio with fire pit (Photo: @MargJohnsonVA via Twenty20)
Vacation home patio with fire pit (Photo: @MargJohnsonVA via Twenty20)

Families and vacation homes are, in many ways, made for each other. But when it’s time to reserve your rental home, it’s important to understand the difference between the many available booking options.

Should you opt for a vacation rental agency or a booking platform for vacation rentals? Though they’re often grouped together, vacation rental companies and vacation rental booking platforms work differently, and provide different levels of assistance and coverage if something goes wrong.

FIND A DEAL: 19 Best Vacation Rental Sites for Cheap Prices

How Does a Vacation Rental Agency Work?

girl relaxing next to packed suitcase
A managed vacation home rental agency is a principal in your rental contract (Photo: @photomasha_symchych via Twenty20)

A managed vacation home rental agency is a principal in your rental contract. That means your booking contract is with the vacation rental agency, not the owner of the property. You pay the booking agency, not the owner, and the agency is responsible for addressing any problems you encounter before, during, or after the rental.

Any financial dispute that arises is also between you and the agency; you don’t have to worry about locating and dealing with an absentee owner—an especially important distinction when you’re renting a vacation home in a foreign location.

The vacation rental agency’s staff is familiar with all the properties it rents. In many cases, staff has personally inspected each property. Typical managed vacation home rental agencies include local conventional travel agencies, property managers, resort operators, and agencies with arrangements with local sources in each destination.

HOW TO DECIDE: Hotels vs. Vacation Rentals: Which Is Better for Families?

In general, renting through a managed vacation home booking agency is less risky than renting through a booking platform. That’s especially important when you’re basing a big-dollar decision on limited online descriptions and pictures.

With a managed vacation rental agency, the risk of encountering a dismal dump a mile from the beach is tiny. And if you do encounter a problem, you know how to reach a responsible party to fix a problem or get a refund—through a credit card chargeback, if necessary.

Managed vacation home rental agencies also tend to focus on the more expensive vacation rentals—larger vacation homes and “villas” in prime locations rather than cottages or cabin rentals. If you’re looking for budget deals, you may not find much. Managed agencies also generally offer only a limited number of choices in any destination. 

How Do Vacation Rental Booking Platforms Work?

Child enjoying outdoor patio heater on vacation (Photo: Shutterstock)
Booking platforms operate like bulletin boards (Photo: Shutterstock)

Booking platforms like Vrbo, FlipKey, AirBnB, and hundreds of small regional companies operate like bulletin boards: They post available rentals and facilitate arrangements, but they are not principals in the rental transaction. They’re pass-throughs, like eBay or Craigslist, only specialized in vacation rentals.

Owners of individual properties list their offerings and pay the platform a fee. The platform posts and indexes the property details and links to the owner with whom you complete the transaction. Typically, the only source of information you have available about a rental property is what the vacation rental booking platform posts, which is what the property owner creates and submits. Generally speaking, nobody with the platform has actually seen or can vouch for the property. 

MAKE MEMORIES: 27 Family Vacation Ideas for a Trip They’ll Never Forget

With a vacation rental booking agency, your rental contract is with the property owner; the platform is no more than an intermediary through which the transaction passes. If you encounter a problem, you need to find and contact the property owner or representative, and if you’re due a refund, you have to arrange it with the owner. Many owners do not accept credit cards, instead asking for cash transfer.

For those reasons, booking through a platform can be somewhat riskier than booking through a managed vacation rental agency. But most big platforms have adopted various methods to minimize misrepresentation and fraud, and they’ve arranged to accept credit cards on many bookings for added consumer protection. All in all, the risks of booking a vacation rental through a platform are small.

Vacation Rental Agency Listings

Walking among the wildflowers at Garrapata State Park in Monterey, California (Photo: Shutterstock)
Most rental agencies specialize in singular regions rather than worldwide destinations (Photo: Shutterstock)

Although a few agencies offer rentals in popular family vacation spots around the world, most specialize in smaller regions. Agencies concentrating on the U.S. focus on major visitor centers; those outside the U.S. focus on major tourist destinations, especially London, Paris, Provence, and Tuscany.

I’ve compiled a long list of managed agencies, but it’s by no means complete. In each link, I’ve noted areas of focus where it isn’t obvious from the agency name. You can also locate other possibilities by searching a city or area name plus vacation rentals. 

Worldwide Vacation Rental Agency Listings

U.S. Vacation Rental Agency Listings

Multi-Country European Vacation Rental Agency Listings

France Vacation Rental Agency Listings

  • At Home in France:  Vacation rentals in France, including Paris, Provence, the Alps, the Loire Valley, and other regions
  • Dordogne Rental: Chateaux, manor houses, and farmhouses for short-term rent in the Dordogne region in the southwest of France
  • France for Rent: Paris apartment rentals 
  • France Homestyle: Vacation rentals in France (plus additional vacation rentals in Italy)
  • Kestrel Travel: Concierge-service villas on the French Riviera and in Provence
  • South France Holiday Rentals: Small selection of holiday rentals in the South of France

Italy Vacation Rental Agency Listings

  • Homebase Abroad : Vacation villas in Italian locations including Tuscany, the Dolomites, Lake Como, Venice, and Rome
  • Resorts in Italy: Vacation rentals in cities and towns around Italy
  • Salogi Villas & Farmhouses: Vacation rentals in Italy; primarily focused on vacation homes in Tuscany but also has listings elsewhere in Italy.
  • To Tuscany: Family villas, villas with pools, and luxury villas in Tuscany 
  • Tuscany Now & More: Serviced villas with pools in Tuscany

U.K. Vacation Rental Agency Listings

Spain Vacation Rental Agency Listings

  • Esteponia Villas and Mijas Villas: Vacation rentals in and around the towns of Esteponia and Mijas on Spain’s Costa del Sol
  • Home Club: Nightly and monthly vacation rentals around Spain.

Mexico and Caribbean Vacation Rental Agency Listings

Island Vacation Rental Agency Listings

More from FamilyVacationist:

Posted: July 2020
Updated: July 2022

Tags:
Ed Perkins
Ed Perkins
View More Posts
Ed Perkins is a longtime consumer advocate and reporter. He spent 25 years in travel research and consulting and was founding editor of Consumer Reports Travel Letter. His travel expertise has led to frequent television appearances, including ABC's Good Morning America, The CBS Evening News, CNN, and numerous local TV and radio stations.